Integration of the Ukrainian Higher Education Into the Global Educational Space

Pol­gá­ri Szem­le, 13. évf., 4–6. szám, 2017, 375–379., DOI: 10.24307/psz.2017.1227

Diana Ku­che­ren­ko, PhD, As­so­ci­a­te Pro­fes­sor, Sci­en­ce and Re­se­arch Ins­ti­tu­te of So­ci­al and Eco­no­mic De­ve­lop­ment, Kyiv (ndi@​knutd.​com.​ua).

Sum­ma­ry

Analy­sis of the mo­dern glo­bal mar­ket fea­tu­res, iden­ti­fi­ca­ti­on of the key di­rec­tions in the de­ve­lop­ment of an ef­fi­ci­ent edu­ca­ti­o­nal po­li­cy in the Uk­raine and met­hods of ac­ce­le­rat­ing the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces.

Jour­nal of Eco­no­mic Li­te­ra­tu­re (JEL) codes: I21, I23
Key­words: edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket, hig­her edu­ca­ti­on, the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces


Main re­se­arch prob­lem

The main sys­tem cha­rac­te­r­is­tics of glo­ba­li­za­ti­on inc­lu­de re­vo­lu­tions in in­for­ma­ti­on and com­mu­ni­ca­ti­on, growth in trans­na­ti­o­nal re­se­arch and edu­ca­ti­o­nal net­works and re­la­ti­onsh­ips, in­te­gra­ti­on of the world eco­nomy and the com­pe­tit­ion bet­ween na­tions and mar­kets. Among these cir­cum­stan­ces, our count­ry must cle­arly iden­ti­fy pri­o­ri­ti­es for the edu­ca­ti­o­nal sys­tem to en­sure its in­ter­na­ti­o­nal com­pe­ti­ti­ve­ness.

From an in­dust­ri­al so­ci­ety we have moved to­wards an eco­nomy based on know­ledge. The com­pe­ti­ti­ve­ness of the eco­nomy is de­ter­mi­ned by the vo­lu­me of pro­duc­ti­on or by na­tu­ral re­sour­ces, espe­ci­ally by in­tel­lec­tu­al po­ten­ti­al, in other words, under the pre­sent con­di­tions the main sour­ces of know­ledge and in­for­ma­ti­on. Know­ledge be­co­mes a sour­ce of we­alth for an in­di­vi­du­al and for the state in ge­ne­ral.

Edu­ca­ti­on is one of the most im­por­tant com­po­nents of human de­ve­lop­ment. Today the highly de­vel­oped na­tions of the world cle­arly de­monst­ra­te how im­por­tant the sys­tem of hig­her edu­ca­ti­on is in the imp­le­men­ta­ti­on of struc­tu­ral re­forms, in­no­va­ti­on, human fre­e­dom and imp­ro­ve­ment, we­alth, gro­wing needs, so­ci­al se­cu­rity and so on. The glo­ba­li­za­ti­on of the world, the rapid de­ve­lop­ment in sci­en­ti­fic re­se­arch and new in­for­ma­ti­on tech­no­lo­gi­es re­qu­i­re ac­ce­le­ra­ted de­ve­lop­ment in ad­van­ced, in­no­va­tive edu­ca­ti­on, the cre­a­ti­on of con­di­tions for the ad­van­cement of per­so­na­lity, in­tel­li­gen­ce and spi­ri­tu­a­lity. Today we can speak of a new kind glo­ba­li­za­ti­on in the world mar­ket of hig­her edu­ca­ti­on, with mass dis­t­ri­bu­ti­on in edu­ca­ti­on seen as a gu­a­ran­tee of the count­ry’s com­pe­ti­ti­ve­ness in the new glo­bal eco­nomy. The­re­fo­re, studying the trends in and con­se­qu­en­ces of glo­ba­li­za­ti­on in the world mar­ket of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces for the edu­ca­ti­o­nal sys­tem of the Uk­raine is im­por­tant and ur­gent.

Analy­sis of re­cent re­se­arch and pub­li­ca­tions

The chal­len­ges of glo­ba­li­za­ti­on in the edu­ca­ti­o­nal space are dis­cus­sed by Uk­ra­i­ni­an and fo­rei­gn sci­en­tists, na­mely F. Alt­ba­ha, L. Ver­bits­ky, A. Dz­huryns­ky, A. Ly-fe­ro­va, J. Knight, L. Ode­riya, R. Pa­to­ry, O. Sa­hi­no­voyi, P. Scott, Hans de Vita. The op­por­tuni­ti­es for the in­te­gra­ti­on of the Uk­ra­i­ni­an mar­ket of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces are dis­cus­sed in V. Zhu­ravs­ky, M. Zgu­rovs­ky and A. And­rush­chen­ko. Howe­ver, a lot of quest­ions re­ma­in open to in­vestiga­ti­on in the field of trends in trans­form­ing edu­ca­ti­on in the Uk­raine to meet mo­dern chal­len­ges of glo­ba­li­za­ti­on of world edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket.

Is­ola­ti­on uns­ol­ved as­pects of the prob­lem, which the ar­tic­le. In­te­gra­ti­on pro­ces­ses in hig­her edu­ca­ti­on in­ten­si­fi­ed glo­ba­li­za­ti­on, which was the de­ter­mi­ning fac­tor in the de­ve­lop­ment of post-in­dust­ri­al world.

Is­ola­ti­on of the uns­ol­ved as­pects of the prob­lem in the ar­tic­le

In­te­gra­ti­on pro­ces­ses in hig­her edu­ca­ti­on have in­ten­si­fi­ed glo­ba­li­za­ti­on, which was the de­ter­mi­ning fac­tor in the de­ve­lop­ment of the post-in­dust­ri­al world. This is evi­den­ced by the ap­pe­arance of new in­for­ma­ti­on and com­mu­ni­ca­ti­on tech­no­lo­gi­es that serve as new forms of lear­ning and new areas in in­ter­na­ti­o­nal edu­ca­ti­on:

  • Inc­re­a­se in the num­ber of re­se­arch cent­res en­gag­ed in cur­rent is­sues of train­ing and promo­ting the ela­bo­ra­ti­on of app­rop­ria­te pro­pos­als;
  • Eff­orts made by de­vel­oped count­ri­es at the imp­le­men­ta­ti­on of a co­he­rent po­li­cy, and even de­ve­lop a sing­le strategy in the field of edu­ca­ti­on, inc­lu­ding uni­ver­sity (ECTS). Howe­ver, there is an ur­gent need to iden­ti­fy the main di­rec­tions of ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces in the Uk­raine in a glo­ba­li­zing world edu­ca­ti­o­nal space.

The aim of the ar­tic­le is to study the major trends in the glo­bal edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket and the pos­si­bi­lity of inc­re­a­sing the ex­ports of Uk­ra­i­ni­an ser­vi­ces in a glo­ba­li­zed edu­ca­ti­o­nal space.

Pre­s­en­ta­ti­on of the main ma­te­ri­al

Today, the idea of “a glo­bal edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket” as a new pro­cess is ma­ni­fest in the de­ve­lop­ment of in­ter­na­ti­o­nal re­la­tions in train­ing. The glo­ba­li­za­ti­on of edu­ca­ti­on is une­ven: cur­rently the US is in the lead in this area, as it cont­rols one-third of the in­ter­na­ti­o­nal edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket, fol­lo­wed by the Uni­ted King­dom, Ger­many and France by 13, 10 and 9 per­cent, respec­ti­vely. Ac­cord­ing to ex­perts, in 2010 the edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket re­a­ched 110 bil­li­on US dol­lars, and the com­pe­tit­ion will con­ti­nue to in­ten­si­fy.

The glo­ba­li­za­ti­on of hig­her edu­ca­ti­on fits in the pro­cess of in­te­grat­ing edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces as a whole, which inc­lu­des tran­sit­i­on to uni­form edu­ca­ti­o­nal prog­ram­mes. The main con­di­tions of the glo­ba­li­za­ti­on of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces can be iden­ti­fi­ed as:

  • a ge­ne­ral trend in the glo­ba­li­za­ti­on of the world eco­nomy;
  • de­ve­lop­ment in the glo­bal la­bour mar­ket;
  • evo­lut­io­nof the in­for­ma­ti­on so­ci­ety.

The mo­dern ef­fects of glo­ba­li­za­ti­on, which are felt par­ti­cu­larly ac­u­tely after the glo­bal fi­nan­cial cris­is of 2008-2010, have cle­arly high­ligh­ted two gro­ups of count­ri­es: those who be­ne­fi­ted from glo­ba­li­za­ti­on and the los­ers. The win­ners are the eco­no­mi­cally most de­vel­oped count­ri­es and fi­nan­cial and in­dust­ri­al gro­ups est­ab­lis­hed on their basis. The ca­te­gory of los­ers inc­lu­de less de­vel­oped count­ri­es, which have paid hea­vily for a shift to­wards an in­te­gra­ted glo­bal sys­tem both fi­nan­cially and so­ci­ally. Glo­ba­li­za­ti­on is a pro­cess that en­sures the well-be­ing of the strong to the det­ri­ment of the weak. Howe­ver, the pro­ces­ses of glo­ba­li­za­ti­on are ine­vi­tab­le for the Uk­raine as well as most count­ri­es. Thus, at this stage an im­por­tant task is to pre­ser­ve the Uk­ra­i­ni­an iden­tity, cul­tu­re, men­ta­lity and edu­ca­ti­o­nal po­ten­ti­al etc.

An im­por­tant fac­tor in the in­ter­na­ti­o­nal com­pe­tit­ion for the edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket is inc­re­a­se in the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­on to pro­vi­de ad­di­ti­o­nal sour­ces of re­ve­nue for scho­ols, as part of their ima­ges and cre­di­bi­lity and as a ne­ces­sary con­di­ti­on for the ef­fi­ci­ent imp­ro­ve­ment of edu­ca­ti­on and sci­en­ce in the count­ry. Cur­rently, the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces is imp­le­men­ted in the form of four basic mo­dels: stu­dents studying ab­road, dis­tance lear­ning, ope­ning bran­ches and fa­culty exc­han­ge.

In a glo­ba­li­zed edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket a wide range of me­a­sures need to be taken in the Uk­raine to en­sure the pro­tec­ti­on of the in­te­rests of na­ti­o­nal ins­ti­tu­tions and to ac­ce­le­ra­te the pro­cess of in­te­gra­ti­on into the edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket by inc­re­a­sing the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces th­ro­ugh the fol­lo­wing:

  • Ac­cess for fo­rei­gn stu­dents re­ce­i­ving edu­ca­ti­on in uni­ver­sit­i­es in the Uk­raine, inc­lu­ding the fa­ci­li­ta­ti­on of entrance exams, visas for fo­rei­gn stu­dents, do­cu­men­ta­ti­on and free ac­cess to in­for­ma­ti­on;
  • Govern­ment sup­port for stu­dents’ stu­di­es ab­road, cur­rently inc­re­a­singly fun­ded by pri­vate phi­lanth­ro­p­ists and fo­un­da­tions in the Uk­raine. A good examp­le to fol­low is the co­ope­ra­ti­on bet­ween the state and stu­dents in India, where stu­dents are exempt from the pay­ment of tu­i­ti­on fees and other costs of studying ab­road if they re­turn to work in their hom­eland.
  • Inc­re­a­se in the num­ber of li­cen­sed train­ing pla­ces in the most pres­tigi­o­us edu­ca­ti­o­nal ins­ti­tu­tions of the Uk­raine;
  • The use of mar­ke­ting tools, inc­lu­ding a set of me­a­sures aimed at inc­re­a­sing de­mand for edu­ca­ti­on ser­vi­ces do­m­es­tic ins­ti­tu­tions;

In our opin­ion, the main const­ra­ints to the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces and to the est­ab­lish­ment of a com­pe­ti­tive edu­ca­ti­o­nal en­vi­ron­ment in the Uk­raine inc­lu­de inc­lu­de the fol­lo­wing:

1. Un­stab­le po­li­ti­cal en­vi­ron­ment, and as a re­sult, lower se­cu­rity in train­ing;

2. The fast de­ve­lop­ment of new and com­pe­ti­tive glo­bal edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket par­ti­ci­pants. The cur­rent world mar­ket for edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces has three major com­pe­ting mar­kets:

  • North Ame­ri­can (US and Ca­na­da);
  • Euro­pe­an mar­kets (UK, Ger­many and France). Today, the edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket is gro­wing in­ten­si­vely, new and tra­di­ti­o­nal uni­ver­sit­i­es are imp­ro­ving the qu­a­lity of their ser­vi­ces, while in many count­ri­es, par­ti­cu­larly in the Uk­raine, Rus­sia and Euro­pe, de­po­pu­la­ti­on, dec­li­n­ing birth rates, dec­re­a­se in the ratio of young people pose major prob­lems;
  • Pa­ci­fic mar­kets (Aust­ra­lia, New Ze­aland and Japan). Ac­cord­ing to many ex­perts, the Far Ea­s­tern re­gi­on has an inc­re­a­sing share in the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces, as their growth rates are sig­ni­fi­cantly hig­her than that of other mar­ket par­ti­ci­pants, which al­lows the evo­lu­ti­on of a fo­urth edu­ca­ti­o­nal cent­re (China and Sin­ga­po­re);

3. Dis­pa­rity bet­ween the qu­a­lity of edu­ca­ti­o­nal re­qu­i­re­ments in the glo­bal edu­ca­ti­o­nal pro­cess;

4. Low-qu­a­lity ma­nag­ement in edu­ca­ti­on, and as a re­sult, high le­vels of ob­so­le­te lo­gis­tics, which in turn re­du­ces the qu­a­lity of the tea­ch­ing staff;

5. Lack of govern­ment sup­port for the train­ing of local stu­dents ab­road and the low level of in­vestment in the de­ve­lop­ment of sci­en­ces.

6. Un­su­i­ta­bi­lity and lack of pre­pa­ra­ti­on by na­ti­o­nal uni­ver­sit­i­es for tea­ch­ing fo­rei­gn stu­dents.

An ob­jec­tive as­sess­ment of the cur­rent state of the edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket in the Uk­raine re­ve­als that the key com­pe­ti­tive ad­van­ta­ges in the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces, which may serve to att­ract fo­rei­gn stu­dents, are the low price of tu­i­ti­on, the fun­da­men­tal app­ro­ach to tea­ch­ing a sub­ject, and the adopt­ion of the Bo­lo­gna pro­cess in the cur­ri­cu­lum.

Conc­lu­sions

The cur­rent pro­ces­ses of glo­ba­li­za­ti­on in all sphe­res of so­ci­al life inc­lu­de the buil­ding of a sing­le edu­ca­ti­o­nal space based on the in­te­gra­ti­on of na­ti­o­nal mar­kets and edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces, and on the har­mo­ni­za­ti­on of edu­ca­ti­o­nal stan­dards. In the cur­rent con­text of glo­ba­li­za­ti­on at all le­vels of the func­tion­ing of na­ti­o­nal eco­no­mi­es in the world, the main trend of the glo­bal edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket – as part of the so­ci­al and eco­no­mic sys­tem – is in­te­gra­ti­on. The Uk­raine de­ter­mi­nes its place in this pro­cess to en­sure that the edu­ca­ti­on pro­vi­ded in the count­ry is com­pe­ti­tive in the Euro­pe­an and in the glo­bal edu­ca­ti­o­nal space, and can still have a se­cu­re and mo­bi­le la­bour mar­ket. An im­por­tant as­pect in the in­te­gra­ti­on of the Uk­ra­i­ni­an and the glo­bal edu­ca­ti­o­nal space it sho­uld re­ma­in fo­cu­s­ed on the com­pe­ti­tive ad­van­ta­ges of its do­m­es­tic hig­her edu­ca­ti­on sys­tem (low cost and fo­rei­gn na­ti­o­nals’ ac­cess to hig­her edu­ca­ti­on). At the same time, cons­ide­rab­le work needs to be done to re­du­ce the im­pact of ne­ga­tive fac­tors. The­re­fo­re, the Uk­raine sho­uld se­ri­o­usly cons­ider the opt­ion of inc­re­a­sing the ex­port of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces, the re­la­ti­onship bet­ween tra­di­ti­o­nal and non-tra­di­ti­o­nal forms of edu­ca­ti­on, and the com­pe­ti­ti­ve­ness edu­ca­ti­on.

Pros­pects for the use of the re­se­arch re­sults

In­ter­na­ti­o­nal ex­pe­ri­en­ce shows that the vast ma­jo­rity of the edu­ca­ti­o­nal mar­ket con­sists of pub­lic and pri­vate sec­tors. The pub­lic sec­tor re­im­bur­ses edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces. In the pri­vate (non-govern­men­tal) sec­tor edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces are sold and con­sum­ed at mar­ket pri­ces. In this mar­ket, edu­ca­ti­o­nal ser­vi­ces are pro­vi­ded in com­mer­ci­al ins­ti­tu­tions or in govern­ment agen­ci­es pro­vi­ding ser­vi­ces on a cont­rac­tu­al basis. Fu­tu­re re­se­arch could be di­rec­ted at the in­ter­na­ti­o­nal ex­pe­ri­en­ce in and the in­ter­na­ti­o­na­li­za­ti­on fea­tu­res of edu­ca­ti­o­nal ac­ti­vi­ti­es in pub­lic and pri­vate hig­her edu­ca­ti­on ins­ti­tu­tions, and in the me­chan­isms of att­rac­ting pri­vate-sec­tor fund­ing for uni­ver­sit­i­es and other edu­ca­ti­o­nal ins­ti­tu­tions.

Re­fe­ren­ces

De­lanty, D.: New model of the uni­ver­sit­i­es. http://​socio.​tamp.​ru/​1.​htm.
Lesh­chen­ko, Iryna T. (2011): Adult Edu­ca­ti­on as a Phe­no­me­non of Con­ti­nu­o­us Edu­ca­ti­on. Glo­bal In­ter­na­ti­o­nal Sci­en­ti­fic Analy­ti­cal Pro­ject, http://​gisap.​eu/​ru/​node/​1380.
Mos­pan, N. (2015): Trends in the De­ve­lop­ment of Fund­ing Me­chan­isms of the Hig­her Edu­ca­ti­on Ins­ti­tu­tions in the Euro­pe­an Union. www.​narodnaosvita.​kiev.​ua/?​page_​id=2644.​
OECD (2013): Fo­rei­gn / in­ter­na­ti­o­nal stu­dents en­rol­led. http://​stats.​oecd.​org/​Index.​aspx?​DatasetCode=RFOREIGN.